The mega-cap stocks that dominate the US markets are just wrapping up a truly-extraordinary earnings season. Naturally this first quarter under Republicans’ new corporate tax cuts fueled surging profits. But sales were up big too, which is no mean feat for massive companies. With sustained growth at this torrid pace impossible, peak-earnings fears are mounting. And valuations stayed extremely expensive exiting Q1.
Four times a year publicly-traded companies release treasure troves of valuable information in the form of quarterly reports. Required by the US Securities and Exchange Commission, these 10-Qs contain the best fundamental data available to investors and speculators. They dispel all the sentimental distortions inevitably surrounding prevailing stock-price levels, revealing the underlying hard fundamental realities.
The deadline for filing 10-Qs for “large accelerated filers” is 40 days after fiscal quarter-ends. The SEC defines this as companies with market capitalizations over $700m. That currently includes every single stock in the flagship S&P 500 stock index, which includes the biggest and best American companies. As Q1’18 ended, the smallest SPX stock had a market cap of $2.1b which was 1/410th the size of leader Apple.
The middle of this week marked 39 days since the end of calendar Q1, so almost all of the big US stocks of the S&P 500 have reported. The exceptions are companies running fiscal quarters out of sync with calendar quarters. Walmart, Home Depot, and Cisco have fiscal quarters ending in April instead of the usual March, so their “Q1” results weren’t out yet as of this Wednesday. They’ll arrive in the coming weeks.
The S&P 500 (SPX) is the world’s most-important stock index by far, weighting the best US companies by market capitalization. So not surprisingly the world’s largest and most-important ETF is the SPY SPDR S&P 500 ETF which tracks the SPX. This week it had net assets of a staggering $256.7b! The iShares Core S&P 500 ETF and Vanguard S&P 500 ETF also track the SPX with $149.9b and $88.5b of net assets.
The vast majority of investors own the big US stocks of the SPX, as they are the top holdings of nearly all investment funds. So if you are in the US markets at all, including with retirement capital, the fortunes of the big US stocks are very important for your overall wealth. Thus once a quarter after earnings season it’s essential to check in to see how they are faring fundamentally. Their results also portend stock-price trends.
Unfortunately my small financial-research company lacks the manpower to analyze all 500 SPX stocks in SPY each quarter. Support our business with enough newsletter subscriptions, and I would gladly hire the people necessary to do it. For now we’re digging into the top 34 SPX/SPY components ranked by market capitalization. That’s an arbitrary number that fits neatly into the tables below, but a commanding sample.
As of the end of Q1’18 on March 29th, these 34 companies accounted for a staggering 41.7% of the total weighting in SPY and the SPX itself! These are the mightiest of American companies, the widely-held mega-cap stocks everyone knows and loves. For comparison, it took the bottom 426 SPX companies to match its top 34 stocks’ weighting. The entire stock markets greatly depend on how the big US stocks are doing.
Every quarter I wade through the 10-Q SEC filings of these top SPX companies for a ton of fundamental data I dump into a spreadsheet for analysis. The highlights make it into these tables below. They start with each company’s symbol, weighting in the SPX and SPY, and market cap as of the final trading day of Q1’18. That’s followed by the year-over-year change in each company’s market capitalization, a critical metric.
Major US corporations have been engaged in a wildly-unprecedented stock-buyback binge ever since the Fed forced interest rates to deep artificial lows during 2008’s stock panic. Thus the appreciation in their share prices also reflects shrinking shares outstanding. Looking at market-cap changes instead of just underlying share-price changes effectively normalizes out stock buybacks, offering purer views of value.
That’s followed by quarterly sales along with their YoY changes. Top-line revenues are one of the best indicators of businesses’ health. While profits can be easily manipulated quarter-to-quarter by playing with all kinds of accounting estimates, sales are tougher to artificially inflate. Ultimately sales growth is necessary for companies to expand, as bottom-line earnings growth driven by cost-cutting is inherently limited.
Operating cash flows are also important, showing how much capital companies’ businesses are actually generating. Using cash to make more cash is a core tenet of capitalism. While most of these elite US companies reported Q1’18 OCFs as they should, some obscured quarterly results by lumping them in with the past 6 or 9 months. So these tables only include Q1 operating cash flows if specifically reported.
Next are the actual hard quarterly earnings that must be reported to the SEC under Generally Accepted Accounting Principles. Late in bull markets, companies tend to use fake pro-forma earnings to downplay real GAAP results. These are derided as EBS earnings, Everything but the Bad Stuff! Companies often arbitrarily ignore certain expenses on a pro-forma basis to artificially boost their profits, which is very misleading.
While we’re also collecting the earnings-per-share data Wall Street loves, it’s more important to consider total profits. Stock buybacks are executed to manipulate EPS higher, because the shares-outstanding denominator of its calculation shrinks as shares are repurchased. Raw profits are a cleaner measure, again effectively neutralizing the impacts of stock buybacks. They better reflect underlying business performance.
Finally the trailing-twelve-month price-to-earnings ratio as of the end of Q1’18 is noted. TTM P/Es look at the last four reported quarters of actual GAAP profits compared to prevailing stock prices. They are the gold-standard metric for valuations. Wall Street often intentionally obscures these hard P/Es by using the fictional forward P/Es instead, which are literally mere guesses about future profits that often prove far too optimistic.
As expected given the largest corporate tax cuts in US history going live, the big US stocks generally reported spectacular Q1’18 results. Sales, OCFs, and earnings surged dramatically! But much of this tax-cut windfall was anticipated, as valuations remained dangerously high at the end of last quarter. It’s hard to imagine such blistering growth of such enormous mega-cap companies being able to persist for long.
Not surprisingly the S&P 500’s top-constituent list was little changed over the past year. Most of these elite American companies investors love only grew larger. Three stocks did claw their way into the top 34 since Q1’17, and their symbols are highlighted in light blue. Boeing, AbbVie, and DowDuPont saw their stocks soar enough to help knock out GE, IBM, and Altria from the ranks of the top 34 big US stocks.
From the ends of Q1’17 to Q1’18, the SPX itself powered 11.8% higher. This past year was one of great anticipation and euphoria for the expected big corporate tax cuts coming soon. These top 34 SPY stocks outperformed the markets considerably, with big average market-cap gains of 14.6% YoY. More capital inflows concentrating in fewer stocks highlights the increasing narrowness and riskiness of these toppy markets.
As bull markets mature, the breadth of their advances increasingly narrows. Investors flock into the best-performing stocks to chase their superior gains. Thus decreasing numbers of market-darling stocks are wielding outsized influence on overall stock-market fortunes. They shoulder more of the burden, which is a double-edged sword. When selling erupts in these leaders for any reason, it hits the broader markets hard.
Ominously the universally-adored and -owned mega-cap tech stocks still dominated the SPX at the end of Q1. That was despite the SPX suffering its first correction in 2.0 years, a sharp-yet-shallow plunge of 10.2% in just 9 trading days. That started to crack this past year’s extraordinary tech-stock euphoria, but that selloff was too short to really change psychology. So investors still love the leading technology stocks.
Apple, Alphabet, Amazon, and Microsoft tower over the rest of the top SPY stocks, alone accounting for 1/8th of the entire SPX’s weighting! Facebook wasn’t far behind at 6th after Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway. In Q1’18 these top 5 tech stocks indeed seemed to earn their keep, with average results far better than the other big US companies. They reported incredible average top-line sales growth of 29.8% YoY!
At 30% annual revenues growth, sales will double about every 2.6 years. That’s never sustainable for long even in far-smaller companies, and is economically impossible at the size and scale of the mega-cap techs. Despite their awesome and amazing success, these 5 US companies aren’t going to take over the entire US economy. This past year was an extreme outlying anomaly that inevitably has to mean revert.
Never before have stock markets relentlessly powered higher to seemingly-endless new record closes with the lowest volatility ever witnessed. Especially with the stock markets literally trading at bubble valuations all year. Never before have the entire American business and investment communities been able to spend over a year eagerly anticipating the biggest corporate tax cuts in US history. 2017 wasn’t normal!
I’ve been blessed to spend decades studying the markets full-time, all day every day. And certainly one of the most stunning revelations is how broadly and deeply stock-market fortunes affect nearly everything else in the entire economy! Record-high stock markets breed epic levels of optimism about the future and thus abnormally-high levels of spending, both from businesses and individuals. That greatly boosts sales.
These mega-cap tech stocks had the great fortune of riding that big-tax-cuts-coming-soon wave of stock-market euphoria. Americans eager to splurge flocked to buy Apple’s latest iPhones and iPads, which are great but expensive products. If the stock markets had ground lower breeding pessimism, that big Apple upgrade cycle would’ve lengthened as people made do with older devices with almost the same functionality.
Businesses rushed to capitalize on the gold rush of surging consumer spending, advertising heavily on both Alphabet and Facebook. They also rushed to expand their online operations by leasing cloud servers and services from Amazon, Microsoft, and Alphabet. What will happen to this huge business spending to market and grow as stock markets roll over and consumers and companies pull in their horns?
The sheer levels of spending over this past totally-unique year that fueled such incredible sales growth aren’t sustainable. Both consumers and businesses racked up huge new debt to fuel their euphoric buying binges. They won’t keep stacking on debt with interest rates rising and the once-in-a-lifetime extreme optimism on big tax cuts soon fading. The mega-cap tech stocks, and all big US stocks, face slowing sales.
The real shock is not that sales ballooned so dramatically in such a perfect year for bullish sentiment, but that Wall Street is arguing such growth is the new norm. These top 34 SPX companies that had reported Q1 results as of this Wednesday had $789.0b of revenues. Those would double about every 5.3 years even at Q1’s average 14.0% YoY growth rate. These 34 companies can’t gobble up the entire world economy!
These big US stocks’ operating cashflows in Q1 highlight the unsustainability of these results. The 24 top SPY components reporting Q1 OCFs saw incredible average gains of 52.5% YoY. There’s just no way giant mature companies can keep expanding their businesses’ cash generation at such blistering rates. OCFs leverage revenues both ways, so naturally sharply-rising sales are going to catapult OCFs higher.
Of course profits also amplify sales, so the corporate profits of these top 34 US companies surged even more dramatically in Q1. They averaged gargantuan growth of 45.9% YoY! While not sustainable, that’s a reasonable 3.3x the increase in sales. The total earnings of the 31 of these 34 giant companies that had reported as of the middle of this week ran a colossal $116.0b, making for profit margins of about 1/7th.
While those are big profits, surprisingly they only grew 3.4% quarter-on-quarter from Q4’17. Remember that quarter was the last under the old higher-corporate-tax regime. Given all the corporate-tax-cut hype leading into Q1’18 which was again the tax cuts’ maiden quarter, you’d think corporate profits would’ve surged far more than 3.4% QoQ. But that gain is somewhat understated given big adjustments on Q4’17 results.
In my recent essay on big US stocks’ Q4’17, I discussed how nearly all of these elite companies had to make significant-to-huge earnings adjustments to account for the new Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017. With corporate tax rates being slashed, the values of existing deferred tax assets and liabilities on many corporate balance sheets changed dramatically. These differences had to be flushed through Q4 income statements.
Basically companies that had overpaid or underpaid their taxes in the past had to adjust for new lower corporate tax rates going forward. The absolute value of all these adjustments for the top 34 US stocks was a mind-boggling $209.2b in Q4’17, dwarfing actual GAAP profits of $112.2b! But interestingly it was a wash overall, with positive profits boosts and negative profits hits evening out to a net gain of just $2.7b.
Without those big one-time corporate-tax-cut earnings adjustments, overall top-34-SPY-company profits were up 6.0% QoQ in Q1’18. That’s big, not still not as hefty as stock-market euphoria seemed to imply was coming. When corporate-sales growth inevitably stalls, so will profits growth. If revenues actually start to shrink, earnings will decline at several times that rate. So the peak-earnings fears are righteous!
Since it’s hard to imagine a better year psychologically for driving big spending than 2017, odds are the corporate-sales environment will mean revert lower with stock-market fortunes and sentiment. And if that indeed proves true, corporate profits have hit or are hitting their high-water mark for a long time to come. We really may not see such crazy earnings growth again until the next secular stock bull tops years into the future.
The SPX-leading market-darling tech stocks Alphabet, Amazon, Microsoft, and Facebook rely heavily on business spending. Last year was a banner year for business confidence on the coming huge tax cuts, leading to giant leaps in spending for online advertising and back-office data services. When the next recession inevitably arrives with the overdue stock bear, much of that euphoric spending will wither and reverse.
On the valuation front, these big US stocks were frightfully expensive exiting Q1’18. They sported scary average trailing-twelve-month price-to-earnings ratios of 46.0x. That’s closing in on double the classic bubble threshold of 28x! Over the past century and a quarter or so, the average fair-value valuation for the stock markets was half that at 14x. So there’s no doubt these stock markets are exceedingly expensive.
Since these TTM P/E ratios came from the end of Q1 before its big surge in earnings, we can attempt to adjust for that. With these top 34 SPX companies’ profits up 6.0% QoQ excluding tax-cut adjustments, we can generously assume valuations fell 10%. But even if that is somehow 20%, the big US stocks’ average P/Es are still well into bubble territory at 36.8x. Traders have anticipated tax-cut profits for over a year.
Thus the big corporate tax cuts’ earnings boost has long since been more than fully priced in. But maybe offsetting these extreme overvaluations a bit is those big TCJA adjustments in Q4. One reason the P/Es of Alphabet and Microsoft are so high is they took colossal $9.9b and $13.8b hits to earnings in Q4’17 to account for lower corporate taxes going forward. These are one-time distortions not reflective of ongoing operations.
But on the other hand, other top US companies had massive profits boosts in Q4 that artificially lowered their own P/Es. Chief among them is Berkshire Hathaway, which enjoyed a gargantuan $29.1b boost to profits in Q4 due to that one-off TCJA adjustment. So its TTM P/E collapsed from 26.4x at the end of Q4 to 10.8x at the end of Q1. The unique Q4 earnings impacts of the tax cuts distorted various P/Es in both directions.
Seeing 33 of these top 34 SPX companies report big one-time profits adjustments in Q4’17 is surely unprecedented in all of history. These won’t roll off of trailing-twelve-month P/E-ratio calculations until the Q4’18 results come out early next year. So unfortunately we are going to suffer distorted P/Es through all of 2018. But since the overall TCJA adjustment was largely flat, the P/E skew should largely cancel out too.
One of the most-bullish arguments for stock markets going forward is large US companies are taking their higher profits from the corporate tax cuts and plowing them into stock buybacks. So Wall Street is salivating at that pushing stock markets to new record highs. Recent developments with mighty Apple, the king of stock buybacks, demand caution on that bullish thesis. Stock buybacks can’t overcome selloffs.
In its Q1’18 results recently reported on May 1st, Apple added a staggering $100b to its record stock-buyback campaign taking it to $310b total. Last quarter alone, Apple spent an all-time-record-for-the-entire-stock-markets $22.8b buying back its own shares! Nevertheless Apple’s stock still slipped 0.9% lower in Q1 because of the SPX correction. Even relatively-mild selling overpowered epic stock buybacks!
If Q1’18 is indeed as good as it gets or darned close, these bubble-valued stock markets are in serious trouble as sales growth mean reverts dramatically lower. That will be leveraged several times or so in earnings. Seeing the top 34 SPY companies’ sales up an average of 14.0% YoY, and the 5 mega-cap tech stocks’ sales skyrocketing 29.8% YoY, can’t be sustainable. This cycle’s peak earnings is likely really here.
That greatly ups the odds that a new bear market is awakening. Thanks to extreme central-bank easing led by the Fed’s radically-unprecedented 7-year-long zero-interest-rate-policy, the SPX’s bull ballooned to freakish proportions. As of late January’s peak, it had extended to a monster 324.6% gain over 8.9 years! That was nearly the second-largest and easily the second-longest stock bull in all of US history.
The powerful stock-market melt-up over the past year to many new all-time highs was a typical late-bull sentiment thing amplified by big-tax-cut-soon-hope euphoria. That extreme optimism greatly boosted corporate sales and profits, but nowhere near enough to rescue valuations from bubble extremes. As psychology mean reverts to neutral then overshoots to bearish, earnings won’t protect stocks from getting mauled.
Despite the recent mild correction, these stock markets remain exceedingly overvalued and dangerous. The big US stocks’ Q1’18 fundamentals prove corporate earnings still remain too low to justify such lofty stock prices. That’s terrifying in 2018 where the Fed and ECB will collectively remove $950b of liquidity compared to last year! Regardless of valuations, this alone would plunge these stock markets into a new bear.
Investors really need to lighten up on their stock-heavy portfolios, or put stop losses in place, to protect themselves from the coming central-bank-tightening-triggered valuation mean reversion in the form of a major new stock bear. Cash is king in bear markets, as its buying power grows. Investors who hold cash during a 50% bear market can double their stock holdings at the bottom by buying back their stocks at half-price!
SPY put options can also be used to hedge downside risks. They are still relatively cheap now with complacency rampant, but their prices will surge quickly when stocks start selling off materially again. Even better than cash and SPY puts is gold, the anti-stock trade. Gold is a rare asset that tends to move counter to stock markets, leading to soaring investment demand for portfolio diversification when stocks fall.
Gold surged nearly 30% higher in the first half of 2016 in a new bull run that was initially sparked by the last major correction in stock markets early that year. If the stock markets indeed roll over into a new bear in 2018, gold’s coming gains should be much greater. And they will be dwarfed by those of the best gold miners’ stocks, whose profits leverage gold’s gains. Gold stocks skyrocketed 182% higher in 2016’s first half!
Absolutely essential in bear markets is cultivating excellent contrarian intelligence sources. That’s our specialty at Zeal. After decades studying the markets and trading, we really walk the contrarian walk. We buy low when few others will, so we can later sell high when few others can. While Wall Street will deny the coming stock-market bear all the way down, we will help you both understand it and prosper during it.
We’ve long published acclaimed weekly and monthly newsletters for speculators and investors. They draw on my vast experience, knowledge, wisdom, and ongoing research to explain what’s going on in the markets, why, and how to trade them with specific stocks. As of the end of Q4, all 983 stock trades recommended in real-time to our newsletter subscribers since 2001 averaged stellar annualized realized gains of +20.2%! For only $12 per issue, you can learn to think, trade, and thrive like contrarians. Subscribe today!
The bottom line is the big US stocks’ latest quarterly results proved amazingly good. Sales and profits both rocketed higher as extreme stock-market optimism and big-corporate-tax-cut hopes fueled massive spending. But that was still nowhere near enough to justify stocks’ bubble valuations, portending way-weaker stock markets ahead. That will sap last year’s exceptional confidence and erode results going forward.
As businesses and consumers pull in their horns and stop borrowing to spend big in this new rising-rate environment, revenues and earnings growth will stall and reverse. That’s what happens after euphoric bull-market tops. That will fuel stock selling dragging the markets lower, which will further weigh on both sentiment and spending. So there’s a very-good chance we are seeing peak earnings in this bull-bear cycle.
Adam Hamilton, CPA
May 11, 2018
Copyright 2000 – 2018 Zeal LLC (www.ZealLLC.com)
Tweet with hash tag #miningfeeds or @miningfeeds and your tweets will be displayed across this site.
|Lincoln Minerals Limited||LML.AX||+125.00%|
|Golden Cross Resources Ltd.||GCR.AX||+33.33%|
|Casa Minerals Inc.||CASA.V||+30.00%|
|Adavale Resources Limited||ADD.AX||+22.22%|
|Athena Resources Ltd.||AHN.AX||+22.22%|
|Azimut Exploration Inc.||AZM.V||+21.98%|
|New Stratus Energy Inc.||NSE.V||+21.05%|
|Dynasty Gold Corp.||DYG.V||+18.42%|
|Azincourt Energy Corp.||AAZ.V||+18.18%|
|Gladiator Resources Limited||GLA.AX||+17.65%|